The Final Concept (more
or less)
The first two concepts and discussion of
their relative merits (or lack thereof) led me down the road to this
third, and essentially final, design--subject to ultimate
refinement and minor changes. In this design, I came up with a
melding of the puritan open-cockpit daysailor--a classic style--and the
slightly more modern fixed coachroof design I originally was playing
with. Certainly the concept I arrived at is not entirely new, and
I relied heavily upon the basic styling and design of some existing
boats, new and old. Still, it was a joyful moment to put this idea
on paper, on top of the blank Triton hull profile, and the design came
to life. Something in the crude drawing just looked right, and I
began to visualize exactly how the finished boat would look ghosting
through the water.
Click here to enlarge.
|
Inspirations
The
Haven 12-1/2
The
Sakonnet 23
The
Bridges Point 24 (Cuddy Version)
Apparently
I'm a Joel White fan, since all three of the above boats were designed
by him.
|
My own thoughts on this concept are that the
Triton hull, which looks completely different without the original deck
configuration is an excellent foil for a basic unadorned cuddy design as
shown above. The drawing doesn't show any details on the deck plan,
but the idea is that the cockpit coamings would essentially sweep around
and become the low cabin trunk at the forward end of the cockpit, and form
a smooth curve around forward of the mast (rather than come to a point as
shown in the three "inspirations" to the right). Click
here for more information on the "design" process.
At the forward end, a crowned coachroof
would curve down to the coamings, forming a basic cuddy cabin. There
will be an aft bulkhead to enclose this small, basic (yet well-finished)
cabin, which will mainly be used for storage. A small diesel engine
will be installed beneath the cockpit sole, and other systems will be
minimal in keeping with the spirit of the boat. This will not be a
boat that doubles as a cruiser (though I suppose die-hards could weekend
aboard), and no such amenities will be included.
The design will retain the
standard Triton hull, though with a new rudder, and the rigging and sail
plan will remain as originally designed with no substantive changes,
though the spar and all rigging will be new. The goal is not to
change or "improve" upon the original sailing ability of the
Triton; instead, the only goal is to create a new deck upon which to sit
and sail this great design.
Massaging the
Concept?
Although I was happy with my more-or-less final
Concept
3, some new photos of older wooden boats in a recent copy of Wooden Boat
magazine inspired me to revisit the general idea I had with Concept
2: a small cabin house entirely aft of the mast, leaving a sleek,
clean foredeck and giving a low-slung appearance. Upon further reflection,
I decided to try a fourth concept, basically the same as Concept 3 above,
but with the small cabin house moved aft so that it is entirely behind the
mast.
Concept 4
I threw together this drawing. The details
are rough, and certain aspects are not quite how I wanted them, but for now at
least the concept is on paper. For example, the deck crown is improperly
drawn outside the cabin trunk, and there are other detail changes I would make
if I decide to go forward with this particular concept. I'm not yet
convinced that I like this one better than Concept 3, but perhaps with further
revisions...
Click here to enlarge.
Basically, it's the same thing as Concept 3, but
with the cabin trunk shortened a small amount and moved aft by several feet,
leaving clear flush foredeck around the mast partners. The cockpit in this
version is still about 9 feet long, which is huge by most standards. Does
this provide a more balanced look to the design? Does it help eliminate
any evidence of that "cab forward" thing that I don't like? Does
the long foredeck make the boat appear sleeker and longer? Or does
it look shorter and stubbier? My own feelings were mirrored by
most people who offered an opinion on the design--Concept 4 is nice
enough, but not as successful overall as Concept 3.
|
This is a very rough sketch, and I'm not sure I like it better at all, but it
was something I wanted to try. I think the design of Concept 3 might
somehow be a bit sleeker, drawing out the lines of the hull better. The
shorter cabin trunk and cockpit of Concept 4 seems to make the boat appear
stubbier. It might just be the execution of the drawing, but I'm not
convinced. Still, the point of these concepts is more to reject certain
things than it is about actually finding the perfect design. The more
ideas I reject, the more clear the final execution becomes.
When I first posted this new
concept the first week of January 2003, I requested input from visitors to the site, as well as other
people. Most responses came back in favor of the general look of Concept
3, though there were positive comments about Concept 4 as well. Given that
I personally liked Concept 3 the best, and that public opinion seemed to also
favor that general idea, I decided to press forward with finalizing that
concept. To those of you who offered, and continue to offer, your
thoughts, opinions and encouragement--thanks!
Isn't that a big
daysailor? This
is a common question I've been receiving from some people to whom I've
mentioned the concept. My own feeling is that no, this is not too
large a boat for a daysailor. Should day boats be much larger?
Well,. I suppose that depends on the individual, but 28 feet, when it is
as compactly designed as the Triton, seems to be an excellent size for a
fine day boat. After all, many, many people own much more
complicated--and larger--sailboats with full accommodations and the like
that are used only for day sails, with no overnight stays. Frankly,
most Tritons are used more for this purpose than for cruising these
days--the overall feeling amongst the boating public is that one needs a
larger boat for effective cruising. (Though
this is hardly germane to the topic, I happen to disagree with this
trend. Why have more when less is often better? That's why I
enjoy sailing and cruising my own Triton, Glissando.) Will
this concept appeal to everyone? Of course not. Few things
do. Really, the concept only has to appeal (firstly) to me, as the
creator, and (secondly) to one realistic and excited buyer--eventually. To
see the concept become more concrete, and the design and construction
planning process, please click below.
Design
and Specifications>
|